top of page

How to Reclaim Your Sense of Control After a Traumatic Experience

Jolene Arasz
Oct 31
7 min read
A therapist comforting an emotional woman covering her face on a couch, illustrating compassionate treatment and family support in Waldwick, NJ.

When Life Stops Feeling Like Your Own

Months after a car accident on Route 17, you still take the long way through back roads. After a frightening medical scare, you check your heart rate a dozen times a day. After a betrayal or an assault, you plan every outing around exits, timing, and who will be there. None of it feels like a choice. It feels like the experience is still making decisions for you.

That loss of control is one of the most common and least talked-about parts of trauma, and it sits at the center of treatment by Jolene Arasz, Psy.D., Inc. Dr. Arasz's work is built on Control Theory, the idea that our anxiety and trauma are rooted in what we cannot control and losing sight of what we can. This guide from our Waldwick practice explains why trauma takes control away, how to start taking it back, and when support helps.

Quick Answers

Question

Direct Answer

Why does trauma make me feel so out of control?

A traumatic event overwhelms your sense of safety, and the body's alarm system can stay in survival mode well after the trauma ends.

Is trying to control everything a trauma response?

Often, yes. Over-checking, rigid routines, and avoidance are attempts to feel safe again.

Where do I start?

Seeking help and incorporating movement throughout the day. Allow the body to do its job of re-regulating the nervous system through movement. 

Can I do this on my own?

It’s best to get professional help after experiencing trauma to minimize traumatization and to understand how to work with the body and brain to get re-regulated and process through the trauma safely. 



Why Does Trauma Leave You Feeling So Out of Control? A Trauma Specialist in Waldwick, NJ Explains

Why can't I just move on? Because trauma is, by definition, an experience that overwhelmed your ability to protect yourself. In that moment, control was taken from you. Afterward, the brain's threat system often stays on high alert, scanning for the next danger and reacting to reminders as if the event were happening again. According to the VA's National Center for PTSD, most people will go through at least one traumatic event in their lifetime, and about 6% will develop PTSD at some point.

As a lead certified trauma specialist in Waldwick, NJ, Dr. Arasz often reminds clients that these reactions are protective, not a sign of weakness. There is also a lot of quiet pressure today to bounce back quickly, to post that you are "doing great," and to treat healing as a project with a deadline. That pressure can make people feel even more out of control when their body does not cooperate with the timeline.

Overcontrol vs. Reclaiming Control: How a Clinical Psychologist in Waldwick, NJ Sees the Difference

If I am trying so hard to stay in control, why do I feel worse? Because many of the strategies that feel protective in the short term end up reinforcing anxiety. A clinical psychologist in Waldwick, NJ looks at whether a behavior is building safety or just keeping fear in charge:

What Trauma Pushes You Toward

What It Costs Over Time

What Reclaiming Control Looks Like

Checking locks, doors, or your phone again and again

The relief fades faster each time, so the checking grows

One clear routine, then trusting that it is done

Avoiding the road, place, or activity tied to the event

Your world gets smaller, and fear grows stronger

Gradual, planned steps back, at a pace you choose

Planning every detail so nothing can surprise you

Exhaustion, and panic when plans change

Flexible plans with one or two backup options

Needing to know where loved ones are at all times

Strain and conflict in close relationships

Agreed check-ins that feel fair to everyone

Pushing memories away or staying constantly busy

Memories return at night or at unexpected moments

Processing the experience safely, with support

Practical Steps to Reclaim Control, Starting This Week

What can I actually do today? Control Theory points to a simple shift: stop pouring energy into what cannot be changed and put it into choices that are yours. Small, repeatable actions rebuild the sense that you are steering your own life again:

When

Action

Why It Helps

Today

Practice slow breathing, movement/exercise, or grounding (name five things you can see) for two minutes

These strategies help re-regulate the nervous and emotional systems in the body and brain, allowing us to then be able to problem-solve.

This week

Set a steady wake and sleep time, meal times, and wind-down routine. Incorporate some exercise into daily routine, even if it’s 10 minutes/day. 

These self-care factors are critical in regulation and recovery. 

Daily

Make one deliberate choice and follow through, however small

Rebuilds trust in your own decisions

Over the next month

Focus on areas of progress and times when you didn’t feel like doing self-care, but you still did it. 

Building back your self-confidence and increasing self-awareness. 

Ongoing

Decide what boundaries you want to establish and maintain in your life and relationships. 

Increases and re-establishes your personal sense of control. 

Go at your own pace. Reclaiming control is not about forcing yourself through fear. It is about choosing when, how, and with whom you take each step.

How Therapy Gives Control Back: EMDR Treatment in Waldwick, NJ and Other Approaches

Will therapy make me relive everything? Trauma treatment is unique for each person. The point is not to relive your trauma, but to access where that trauma is held in the body and teach clients how to use the body to then change the neural networks in the brain. Somatosensory processing is first and foremost in trauma work. Clients learn how their body communicates with them and how the trauma is manifested physically in the body. We then work with the body using various techniques, primarily bilateral stimulation techniques and neural desensitization and integration to establish a felt sense of safety in the body before any cognitive processing. Dr. Arasz will help guide and maintain safety in the trauma work. You set the pace, and stability comes before deeper work. From there, the approach is matched to what is keeping symptoms going. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy helps challenge beliefs like "I can never be safe again." Internal Family Systems helps people understand the protective parts of themselves that took over during and after the trauma. EMDR treatment is used when a specific memory keeps pulling you back. 

If you have been searching for a trauma therapist near me and wondering where to begin, you can send a message to the Waldwick office and ask what a first session looks like.

Reclaiming Control Together: Families, Partners, and Mental Health Education in Waldwick, NJ

How does this affect the people I live with? When one person is fighting to feel safe, the whole household often adjusts around them, sometimes without anyone saying so. Couples sessions and Structural Family Therapy can help partners and parents understand what is happening and replace tiptoeing with routines that work for everyone. Dr. Arasz's broader focus on mental health education in Waldwick, NJ and beyond, through K-12 programs, teacher training, and her book Why On Earth Do I Feel This Way?, rests on the same idea: when people understand how the brain and body respond to threat, they feel less broken and more able to act. That holds for families in Waldwick, Ridgewood, Ho-Ho-Kus, Allendale, Midland Park, and Saddle River alike.

When to Call a Psychologist in Waldwick, NJ

How do I know it is time to reach out? Consider contacting a psychologist in Waldwick, NJ if symptoms have lasted more than a month, if avoidance keeps shrinking your life, if sleep, work, school, or relationships keep slipping, or if you feel you are only getting through the day by controlling everything around you. You do not need a diagnosis to ask for a consultation. Many people looking for PTSD help near me in Bergen County start with one conversation about what they are experiencing and what kind of support fits.

If you or someone you love is thinking about self-harm, do not wait. Call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline.

READY TO FEEL IN CHARGE OF YOUR LIFE AGAIN?

Whether you are coping with trauma, anxiety, other mental health concerns, or strain at home, Dr. Jolene Arasz, Psy.D. offers individual, couples, and family therapy at 93 Franklin Turnpike, Suite 201, Waldwick, NJ.

Schedule a consultation or call (857) 636-0374.

Closing Summary

A traumatic experience often leaves people feeling that their life is no longer in their control, which can lead to hypervigilance, avoidance, rigid routines, and strain in relationships. Reclaiming control starts with re-regulating the body, and establishing boundaries in one’s life. Dr. Jolene Arasz, Psy.D., an anxiety and trauma specialist in Waldwick, NJ, who also treats a range of other mental health and family concerns, uses Control Theory, CBT, Internal Family Systems, Structural Family Therapy, EMDR, and Neural Desensitization and Integration to help people feel steady and in charge again.

Key Takeaways

  • Trauma takes away control in the moment, and the body's alarm can stay on afterward.

  • Over-checking, avoidance, and rigid planning are attempts to feel safe, not flaws.

  • Overcontrol tends to shrink life; reclaiming control expands it.

  • Start small: let the body do its job. 

  • Partners and families can be part of rebuilding a sense of safety.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How long does it take to feel in control again after trauma?

It varies. Some people feel steadier within weeks, while others, especially after repeated or long-term trauma, need more time and support. Progress is rarely a straight line, and setbacks do not erase the progress that has been made.

2. Is it normal to feel worse around anniversaries or reminders?

Yes. Anniversaries, places, smells, and even seasons can bring symptoms back for a while. Planning ahead for those dates and leaning on support can make them easier to get through.

3. Can trauma from years ago still affect my sense of control today?

Yes. Childhood or long-past trauma can shape how much control people feel they need as adults, often without them connecting the two. Therapy can help link past experiences to present patterns and change them.

4. Does Dr. Arasz only treat trauma?

No. She specializes in anxiety and trauma and also treats a range of other mental health concerns and family and relationship difficulties. She works with adolescents, adults, couples, and families, and provides mental health education to schools and communities.

5. How do I contact the Waldwick office?

Call (857) 636-0374, email drjarasz@gmail.com, or use the contact form at drjpsychology.org/contact. The office is at 93 Franklin Turnpike, Suite 201, Waldwick, NJ 07463.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page